Find Your Specialist


Contact Us

    Go Back

    Will Congress Take Away 401k Deduction?

    Congress is considering a shift from pretax benefits for retirement accounts to after-tax, Roth-type plans in its tax reform efforts, warn retirement plan advocacy groups, such as the American Retirement Association and the American Benefits Council. The idea originally was floated by former House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Dave Camp (R-Mich.) in his 2014 tax reform proposal. The Trump Administration has given mixed signals with regard to its intention to change retirement plan tax benefits. Until legislative language is released, the fate of the hugely popular 401(k) model of retirement savings is uncertain. These 401(k) plans represented a $4.8 trillion market as of 2016, according to the Investment Company Institute.

    How 401(k) Deductions Work

    Tax-favored retirement plans, including IRAs and 401(k)s, come in two flavors, pre-tax and after-tax. In traditional, pre-tax plans, a taxpayer contributes pre-tax money to a plan, thereby reducing the taxpayer’s current-year income. This current deduction is a significant tax savings for taxpayers who are in their highest years of earnings. In addition, accumulated earnings in the account grow tax-free. So, taxpayers do not pay any tax on the account until the funds are withdrawn after retirement age, 59 ½, when presumably the taxpayer is in a lower bracket. (Note that there are penalties for early distribution.)

    In Roth 401(k) and Roth IRA plans, the savings are at the back-end. Taxpayer do not get a current deduction for contributing to the plan, but earnings grow tax free and are never taxed at all if the taxpayer follows the rules and waits until 59 ½ to withdraw the accumulated income in the account. In traditional plans, earnings are eventually taxed when withdrawn.

    If Congress eliminates current tax savings for retirement plans and “Rothifies” them, taxpayers would be currently taxed on contributions made by both employers and employees to a retirement plan. The tax savings on accumulated earnings would continue. In Roth-type plans, those earnings would be tax-free upon distribution.

    Huge Revenue-Raiser

    Congress is eyeing the Rothification idea because changing from the current system with mostly pre-tax funding of retirement plans to a Roth system will raise substantial revenue. The Joint Committee on Taxation has estimated that defined contribution plans such as 401(k)s will cost the federal government $583.6 billion between 2016-2020. Traditional IRAs are estimated to cost $85.8 billion in foregone tax revenue over the same period.

    Backlash Has Already Begun

    Attempts to head off the change to retirement savings taxation are already well underway led by industry groups. “Proposals to raise money by reducing such incentives are short-sighted, producing only short-term deficit reduction and causing serious long-term damage to the retirement security of tens of millions of working Americans.” That assessment comes from an American Retirement Association statement on tax reform.

    The ERISA Industry Committee echoes that sentiment: “A drastic shift to Roth contributions could undermine the entire retirement system in this country and undo the progress that has been made through widely favored pre-tax 401(k) plans.” Finally, the Employee Benefits Research Institute is undertaking a survey and research which will be published soon to show how “Rothification” could affect retirement savings in the U.S.


    Despite the popularity of the current tax benefits for retirement savings, these provisions are vulnerable in any tax reform effort. Employers and employees should watch this issue carefully because of the potential dramatic change in personal financial planning that could result if Congress adopts “Rothification.”

    About the Blogger

    Lucia Nasuti Smeal is a guest blogger on tax topics for Frazier & Deeter. Smeal is an attorney, a tax Professor with Georgia State University’s J. Mack Robinson College of Business, and former editor of Tax Notes Today, published by Tax Analysts. Smeal also worked as a legislative analyst for the Congressional Research Service and is a former member of the U.S. House Periodical Press Corps. She is a frequent speaker on current tax developments.

    Related Articles

    Privacy Overview

    When you use or access the Site, we use cookies, device identifiers, and similar technologies such as pixels, web beacons, and local storage to collect information about how you use the Site. We process the information collected through such technologies, which may include Personal Information, to help operate certain features of the Site (e.g., to prevent online poll participants from voting more than once), to enhance your experience through personalization, and to help us better understand the features of the Site that you and other users are most interested in.

    You can enable or disable our use of cookies per category.
    Always Enabled

    Essential cookies enable you to navigate our Site and use certain features, such as accessing secure areas of our Site and using other features of our service that require us to keep track of certain information as you navigate from page to page. Although some of these cookies are “required” to enable certain functionality, you can disable them in the browser, but doing so will limit your ability to use the features supported by such cookies.

    Functionality cookies are cookies that support features of the Site, such as remembering your preferences.

    These cookies collect information about how you use our Site, including which pages you go to most often and if they receive error messages from certain pages. These cookies are only used to improve how our Site functions and performs.

    From time-to-time, we may engage third parties that track individuals who visit our Site. These third parties may track your use of the Site for purposes of providing us with certain marketing automation features (to help us improve our outreach to current and prospective clients) and providing you with targeted advertisements.