Find Your Specialist


Contact Us

    Go Back

    VF Holdings Owes $505 Million Tax Bill

    Lee, Wrangler, Nautica, Vans, and North Face are iconic apparel brands, all owned by VF Holdings through its numerous acquisitions. The company also acquired Timberland Co. in 2011, doubling its global footwear business. That merger, however, has resulted in a $505 million tax bill recently upheld by the Tax Court in TBL Licensing LLC v. Commissioner. The Court found that the outbound transfer of intangible property by the LLC to a foreign holding company resulted in immediately recognizable ordinary income. It was a complicated transaction, and the structure chosen by the parties did not give the intended result.  

    The Transaction and Timing of Income

    Here is a greatly simplified description of the transaction. The deficiency arose from the restructuring carried out after the merger between VF Corp. and Timberland Co. In the restructuring, the Petitioner LLC became the owner of Timberland’s intangible property, including trademarks, foreign workforce, and foreign customer relationships, and then made a constructive transfer of that property to TBL Investment Holdings, a Swiss corporation and subsidiary of VF Enterprises, as part of a Sec. 368(a)(1)(F) reorganization.  

    For the taxable years 2011 through 2017, the LLC included in its income deemed annual payments attributable to the constructive transfer. The IRS argued that, instead, the company should have had an immediate gain taxable as ordinary income upon completion of the transaction.  

    The Court’s Holdings: Pay Up

    The Court examined Code Section 367 and its regulations and concluded that there was no authority for treating the income as earned over time rather than all at once in the year of the transaction. That section was enacted to prevent the avoidance of U.S. taxation on the transfer of property to a controlled foreign corporation and to discourage the removal of appreciated property from the U.S. 

    The Tax Court also rejected the LLC’s argument that the amount of income should be based on a useful life of 20 years, which is allowed in limited circumstances. The Court adopted the IRS view that the constructive transfer was a disposition, and the actual fair market value of the assets and the measure of income should be determined using the property’s entire expected useful life, not limited to 20 years.   


    This case is interesting because it illustrates the technical traps of the international tax rules under U.S. law. The series of transactions ended up having an unintended impact—a big tax hit—even though the parties had extensive experience in completing mergers and even though the merger used a complicated structure designed to result in a minimization of the tax burden. The Tax Court took a strict view of the reorganization nonrecognition rules when coupled with Congress’s intended limitations on transfers of U.S. assets to related foreign companies. An appeal is expected in the case. 

    Related Articles

    • 01.25.2023

      A New Year Means New Privacy Laws

      Ever since the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) came into effect in May 2018, US state privacy laws have been passed in Virginia, Colorado, Connecticut, Utah and, most pressing of them all, California. The California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) went…

      Continue Reading
    • 01.19.2023

      The New Rules Under Section 174

      Internal Revenue Code Section 174 has long been used by taxpayers to deduct certain expenses related to research and experimentation (R&E) in the current year.  The code section was originally enacted in 1954 to eliminate uncertainty in the tax accounting…

      Continue Reading
    • 12.20.2022

      IRS Customer Service May Improve in 2023

      With 4,000 new customer service representatives and plans to hire 700 new Taxpayer Assistance Center (TAC) employees, taxpayers soon may get relief from endless hold times, no in-person help and unresolved problems.

      Continue Reading
    • 12.12.2022

      Reduce Taxable Income with IRA Distributions Transfers

      IRA owners who are age 70½ or over can transfer up to $100,000 per year to charity to reduce their taxable income. These transfers, known as qualified charitable distributions or QCDs, offer end-of-the year tax savings and can count toward required minimum distributions (RMDs) that taxpayers who are age 72 must make each year. Think of it as a tax-free charitable rollover of IRA funds.

      Continue Reading
    • 12.02.2022

      UK R&D Tax Reliefs – Where Are We Now?

      In the November 2022 Autumn Statement, the Chancellor announced significant changes to the current Research and Development (R&D) tax reliefs. The key announcements were a change to the applicable rate of the Research and Development Expenditure Credit (RDEC) and a…

      Continue Reading
    • 12.01.2022

      1099s Required for 2022 Tax Year

      Taxpayers earning income from selling goods or providing services may receive a Form 1099-K, Payment Card and Third-Party Network Transactions, for the first time in early 2023, when the 2022 forms are due. The requirement to file Forms 1099 have…

      Continue Reading
    • 11.28.2022

      IRS Uncovers $3.1 Billion in COVID Fraud

      The IRS Criminal Investigation department (IRS-CI) has partnered with the Justice Department to uncover and prosecute fraudulent activities related to the federal government’s COVID relief programs. To date, the IRS has conducted 840 investigations involving fraud amounts totaling more than…

      Continue Reading
    • 10.25.2022

      IRS Inflation Reduction Act Increases Funds

      The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, enacted in August, increased funding for the IRS by $80 billion through 2031 for enforcement activities, operations support, systems modernization and taxpayer services. The legislative language, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and IRS Commissioner Charles…

      Continue Reading

    Privacy Overview

    When you use or access the Site, we use cookies, device identifiers, and similar technologies such as pixels, web beacons, and local storage to collect information about how you use the Site. We process the information collected through such technologies, which may include Personal Information, to help operate certain features of the Site (e.g., to prevent online poll participants from voting more than once), to enhance your experience through personalization, and to help us better understand the features of the Site that you and other users are most interested in.

    You can enable or disable our use of cookies per category.
    Always Enabled