Contact us
Home › Beyond the Balance Sheet: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes in Pension Valuations

Insights & Resources

•

Beyond the Balance Sheet: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes in Pension Valuations

Beyond the Balance Sheet: How to Avoid Costly Mistakes in Pension Valuations

Filed under

When most people think about dividing assets in a divorce, they picture houses, cars and bank accounts. But some of the most significant assets in a marital estate don’t appear on a monthly statement — they’re embedded in pension plans and retirement benefits that can dramatically impact long-term financial security.

For many attorneys, pensions are a mystery until they suddenly become central to the case. By then, it’s often too late to correct costly oversights.

The Hidden Value of Pensions

In one recent case, a $180,000 pension was divided using a quick, back-of-the-envelope calculation. Months later, a proper valuation revealed it was actually worth more than $340,000. The difference wasn’t an error in math — it was a misunderstanding of what the pension truly represented.

Each plan type — federal, state, corporate or military — has unique rules that can significantly affect value. Some include cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) that compound over decades. A modest monthly benefit today can become a substantial income stream at retirement when those adjustments are properly factored in.

Without a detailed review of plan documents and assumptions, even well-intentioned estimates can miss the mark by tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The Real Cost of Late Valuations

The biggest mistake in pension valuation isn’t getting the wrong number — it’s getting the number too late. Discovery takes time, and some plan administrators move slowly. When a valuation is ordered at the last minute, it limits options for negotiation and increases the risk of an inequitable division.

We often see cases where attorneys had to finalize settlements based on incomplete or delayed data. Once those agreements are signed, correcting valuation errors can require additional litigation — an outcome that adds cost and stress for everyone involved.

Three Practical Tips for Attorneys

  1. Order the valuation early.
    It’s far easier to adjust your strategy with accurate data in hand than to revisit an agreement later. Early valuations also reveal potential issues with documentation or plan interpretation.
  2. Always ask about cost-of-living adjustments.
    A pension that looks modest on paper may double, or triple, in real value when compounded over 20 or 30 years. COLA provisions can dramatically alter the financial picture.
  3. Work with an expert who reads the fine print.
    Every pension plan is different. Generic calculations or online estimators can overlook key details like early retirement penalties, survivor benefits or service credit rules. A forensic accountant with pension experience knows how to interpret the plan documents and apply the right actuarial assumptions.

The Human Side of the Numbers

Behind every spreadsheet are real-world stakes that can shape the outcome of a case. Even individuals who feel confident about their finances may find that complex assets — pensions, retirement accounts or multi-entity holdings — require careful analysis. Explaining these nuances clearly and accurately can make a significant difference in settlement or litigation outcomes.

At Frazier & Deeter, we approach these valuations with both precision and insight. Our Forensic Accounting & Litigation Support Practice has deep experience across pension types — from government and military plans to corporate and hybrid models — and we work closely with attorneys to ensure that every number reflects the true long-term value of the assets involved.

A Clearer Path Forward

Divorce is never just a financial process; it’s an emotional and often overwhelming transition. But when it comes to pensions and retirement assets, information is power. Early involvement of a qualified forensic accountant ensures that clients receive the clarity and confidence they need to move forward — and that attorneys have the facts to advocate effectively.

Because sometimes, what’s off the balance sheet can make all the difference.

When early insight matters, the right forensic expertise makes all the difference. Contact FD to discuss how we can support your cases with accurate valuations, thorough analysis and expert guidance.

Contributors

Jennica Moore, Senior Manager, Frazier & Deeter Advisory, LLC

Explore related insights

Explore Insights & Resources